Evidence literacy

Last year's aquariums are not a concurrent control

Audit a historical aquarium comparator by recording period, supplier, scorer and missing chemistry separately.

By FishyMag · Published

Original research-appraisal case · Not a clinical review or treatment recommendation.

Quick answer

The fictional comparison uses four current exposed tanks and four untreated tanks from an earlier period. The comparator is historical. Supplier and scoring-team differences are documented, while some water chemistry remains unknown. Those differences are not established causes of the outcome.

AI-generated illustration of an open record book and clock on a dry table beside a planted aquarium; no actual research experiment or measured result is shown.
AI-generated editorial illustration. Also used in related FishyMag guides. Not a photograph of FishyMag testing or a treatment demonstration.

Make the date part of the control definition

A group described as untreated may come from a different study period. Here, the four exposed aquariums are current, while the four untreated aquariums are archived from an earlier run. ARRIVE calls for transparent group, animal and procedure descriptions. This original case applies those reporting questions to comparator provenance; it does not assert that a historical comparison is automatically unusable.

Separate known differences from missing information

The fictional archive names a different animal supplier and a different scoring team. It lacks some water records. Missing chemistry must remain unknown rather than being treated as matched or changed.

Separate known differences from missing information: worked table
DimensionCurrent exposed groupHistorical untreated groupFinding
Study periodCurrentEarlierNot concurrent
Tank count44Equal counts do not match periods
Animal supplierBADocumented difference
Scoring team21Documented difference
Some water chemistryCurrent record availableArchived record unavailableComparability unresolved
Same-period untreated outcomeNot suppliedHistorical onlyConcurrent contrast absent from packet

Write the conclusion the archive can support

The result compares exposed current tanks with untreated tanks from an earlier period under partly different documented conditions. That is more informative than simply saying “compared with controls.” It does not show that the supplier or scorer produced the difference, and it does not establish what a concurrent group would have shown. Request the archived methods, raw scoring definitions, animal provenance and missing water records where they exist. If they cannot be recovered, preserve that limitation in any downstream summary. Avoid converting an unavailable comparison into a positive compatibility finding or dismissing the reported observations as fabricated.

Use your own details

Last year's aquariums are not a concurrent control worksheet

Download the editable text file, fill it in on your device and keep it with the relevant record. This blank worksheet records your information; it does not verify entries or approve treatment.

  1. Current study period and tank roster
  2. Comparator study period and tank roster
  3. Animal source for each period
  4. Scoring team and scoring definition
  5. Water records available for both periods
  6. Missing archived measurements
  7. Concurrent comparison availability
  8. Bounded conclusion and record request
Download worksheet (.txt)

Put it into practice

Your checklist

  • Identify whether the comparator is concurrent or historical.
  • Keep documented differences separate from unavailable records.
  • Do not turn a comparability concern into an invented causal explanation.

Sources and scope

This article distinguishes manufacturer statements from FishyMag’s own workflows and arithmetic examples. Linked formulation records retain their own evidence dates; publishing this article does not refresh those records.

AI-assisted writing and development. Not hands-on product testing or veterinary review. How we publish →

FishyMag reports what manufacturers say, quoted and linked. It does not diagnose illness or recommend a treatment, and it never infers that a product is safe from the absence of a warning — where no statement exists, it says so.

Formulations change. Always read the label on the bottle in your hand, and contact the manufacturer if your tank contains anything valuable or unusual.

Continue exploring