Keeper workflows

One aquarium study, two publication versions

Reconcile a preprint and publication by experiment identifiers, then track substantive wording changes.

By FishyMag · Published

Original source audit · Not a clinical review or treatment recommendation.

Quick answer

The fictional preprint P and journal article J are two versions of the same documented experiment, E-17. Their titles, author order and endpoint presentation differ. A third paper shares authors but lacks enough detail to determine whether it shares the data.

Photograph of many small tagged tanks in the Weizmann Institute zebrafish laboratory.
Research aquarium tanks at the Weizmann Institute. A tank identifier can help trace an experiment across versions; this photograph shows no preprint or journal lineage. Also used in related FishyMag guides. Resized on a white canvas and converted to WebP. The adapted photograph retains CC BY-SA 4.0. Photo: Deror_avi. Fish Laboratory in Weizmann Institute IMG 8814 · CC BY-SA 4.0.

Match identifiers beneath the titles

The fictional preprint and journal publication both name experiment E-17, twelve allocated tanks and the same collection dates. The journal version links to the preprint. Crossref supports an explicit preprint relationship; matching details in the documents support the relationship in this worked case. Paper K shares two authors but does not supply a cohort ID or matching dates.

Compare the passages the claim depends on

Different wording does not automatically establish new data or a different experiment.

Compare the passages the claim depends on: worked table
FieldPreprint PJournal J
Study and allocationE-17, same twelve tanksE-17, same twelve tanks
Title and bylineEarlier title and orderChanged title and author order
Feeding presentationNarrative in results paragraph 2Day-four count moved to Table 3
Exposure languageTiming in methods sectionTiming defined in methods plus appendix
Paper KOverlapping authors onlyLineage unresolved

Cite the current passage without counting two experiments

When referring to the table, use the journal version and retain the preprint link in the record. Reassess any statement copied from the earlier text that no longer matches the current wording. This is a version audit, not an estimate of how many experiments Paper K contains.

Use your own details

One aquarium study, two publication versions worksheet

Download the editable text file, fill it in on your device and keep it with the relevant record. This blank worksheet records your information; it does not verify entries or approve treatment.

  1. Preprint and version-of-record identifiers
  2. Study, tank allocation and collection dates
  3. Version link from repository or publisher
  4. Exact changed passages and tables
  5. Same and missing lineage evidence
  6. Citation to use for current claim
  7. Unknown third-paper relationship
Download worksheet (.txt)

Put it into practice

Your checklist

  • Match study IDs, tanks and dates.
  • Track changes to passages used for claims.
  • Leave a third paper’s lineage unresolved when only authors overlap.

Sources and scope

This article distinguishes manufacturer statements from FishyMag’s own workflows and arithmetic examples. Linked formulation records retain their own evidence dates; publishing this article does not refresh those records.

AI-assisted writing and development. Not hands-on product testing or veterinary review. How we publish →

FishyMag reports what manufacturers say, quoted and linked. It does not diagnose illness or recommend a treatment, and it never infers that a product is safe from the absence of a warning — where no statement exists, it says so.

Formulations change. Always read the label on the bottle in your hand, and contact the manufacturer if your tank contains anything valuable or unusual.

Continue exploring